Five Mistakes to Avoid When Filing a Small Claim in Los Angeles

· @Junhui Joo

We live in a jungle where the fittest survive, and money matters. Some people ask for far more than they are owed. Others try to take your money whenever they see a chance. When that happens, small claims court can feel like the one place where an ordinary person can fight back without hiring a lawyer.

As a State of California court certified interpreter, I have interpreted in hundreds of small claims hearings in Los Angeles. I have watched people win cases they should have lost and lose cases they should have won. Most of the time, the difference was not the law. It was preparation.

Here are five mistakes I see again and again, and how to avoid them.

Mistake 1: Filing a claim without a real reason

The first mistake can be filing the claim at all. Some people file without any real basis. They heard somewhere that you can win money if the other side does not show up, or shows up poorly prepared.

The thinking goes like this: even if I lose, what is the risk? In Los Angeles, judges rarely make a losing plaintiff pay the other side for their time or trouble. So why not try?

Here is why not. Every hearing costs you time, filing fees, service costs and stress. You have to spend time to prepare and appear. And the other party may not be as weak as you hoped. I have seen many plaintiffs walk in confident and walk out with nothing, because the defendant arrived with receipts, photos and witnesses.

There is one more thing many people don’t know. In California, a plaintiff who loses in small claims court generally cannot appeal their own claim. The defendant can appeal, but you cannot. You get one chance.

Before you file, talk your case over with someone knowledgeable:

  • An attorney, if you can afford a consultation. Attorneys cannot speak for you at a small claims hearing, but they can tell you whether your case is strong.
  • The free small claims advisor offered by Los Angeles County’s Department of Consumer and Business Affairs.
  • An experienced Legal Document Assistant (LDA). An LDA cannot give legal advice, but can help you prepare your claim forms correctly and on time, following your instructions.

Mistake 2: Not serving the other party on time

Filing your claim is only the beginning. The other party must be formally notified, and the rules are strict.

Serving the claim. Your claim must be served at least 15 days before the hearing, or 20 days if the other party is in a different county. You cannot serve it yourself. An adult who is not part of the case, such as a friend, a relative or a professional process server, must do it. The server then fills out a Proof of Service (form SC-104), which you file with the court at least 5 days before the hearing.

Exchanging evidence. In Los Angeles, you are also expected to send copies of your evidence to the other party and to the court before the hearing. The Los Angeles Superior Court’s form for this, LASC CIV 278, requires the evidence to arrive at least 10 days before the hearing, by mail or personal delivery. List each item on the form as proof that you sent it. I recommend giving yourself extra time and mailing everything about 15 days ahead.

If you skip these steps, the judge may refuse to consider your evidence or postpone the case. A postponement in Los Angeles can push your hearing back by weeks or even a couple of months. That means more time off work and more stress.

Also make sure the court actually receives your evidence ahead of time, through the clerk or the court’s filing options. A judge who has read your evidence before the hearing is a judge who understands your case.

Mistake 3: Coming to court without enough evidence

Just today, I interpreted for a plaintiff who was asking for $12,000 in damages. When the judge asked what proof he had, he had nothing but his own story. The judge cannot award money based on how upset someone is.

In small claims court, it is your job as the plaintiff to prove that the other party owes you money, and how much. Your word against theirs is rarely enough. Bring documents that show the judge exactly where your number comes from:

  • Receipts and invoices
  • Cancelled checks, bank statements or payment records
  • Contracts, leases or written agreements
  • Text messages and emails in which the other party admits the debt or the problem
  • Photos or videos of damage, with dates
  • Repair estimates from licensed businesses

Organize your evidence in the order you will talk about it. Bring three copies of everything: one for the judge, one for the other party and one for yourself. If a document is in another language, have it translated by a qualified translator so the judge can read it.

Mistake 4: Refusing to settle when your case is weak

Many people come to court determined to get every dollar they asked for. They see any compromise as losing. That pride can be expensive.

Before the judge rules, there is usually a chance to talk. The parties may have already exchanged evidence, and on the hearing day the court often gives people time to speak in the hallway or with a volunteer mediator. Use that chance. Read the other side’s evidence honestly and ask yourself how it will look to the judge.

If your case has holes, a settlement may be the best result you can get. Even if you truly believe you deserve the money, the judge may see it differently. I have watched many people refuse a fair offer, go before the judge, and leave with nothing.

As the old saying goes, a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush. Receiving part of what you asked for is far better than spending months of time and money and losing it all. A written settlement also has the benefit of being something both sides agreed to, which often makes it easier to collect.

Mistake 5: Starting with a long introduction

Many people imagine their day in court like a TV drama, with plenty of time to tell the whole story from the beginning. Real small claims court in Los Angeles is nothing like that.

Unlike some courts in Orange County, a Los Angeles small claims judge may have 20 or more cases on the calendar in a single session. You might get five minutes. Often the judge will skip your speech entirely and simply ask questions.

I regularly see people start with background: how they met the other party, what kind of person they are, how much stress they have been under. Before they reach the important part, the judge cuts them off. They leave feeling they never got to tell their side.

Instead, prepare a two-minute statement that answers three questions:

  1. What happened? One or two sentences.
  2. Why does the other party owe you? The agreement they broke or the damage they caused.
  3. How much, and how do you know? The amount, and the documents that prove it.

Practice it out loud with a timer. Then let the judge lead. Answer exactly what you are asked, briefly, and point to your evidence as you go. The judge is asking about what matters most for the ruling, so that is where your energy should go.

Protect your money with good preparation

Small claims court can protect you from people who try to take what is yours. But it rewards the prepared, not the angry. Think carefully before you file, serve the other party on time, bring solid evidence, stay open to settlement, and get to the point.

If you are preparing a small claim in Los Angeles, L.A. Legal Document Assistants can help you prepare your forms and paperwork correctly and on time, based on your instructions. We are a registered and bonded Legal Document Assistant service, and we bring more than 20 years of experience in Los Angeles courts. Call us at (844) 223-3137 or email info@la-legaldocumentassistants.com.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. A Legal Document Assistant is not an attorney and cannot give legal advice. Court rules and deadlines can change, so check the current requirements with the Los Angeles Superior Court or the county’s small claims advisor before you file.

Sources